Household Ingredients Compared › Hoisin and Black Bean Sauce (Singapore)
Hoisin sauce is sugar first — in the Lee Kum Kee recipe sugar is the first ingredient and added sugars run to about 45g per 100g. Black bean sauce is fermented black beans first, and the two sauces are not interchangeable: hoisin is sweet and used for dipping and glazing, black bean sauce is savoury and used for stir-frying. The Singapore shelf is Lee Kum Kee first, with Amoy, Singlong and FairPrice house brand alongside. Watch for the colour: the US Lee Kum Kee hoisin contains Red 40 (E129); the international recipe does not.
This page does not give a health score or a "best" pick. It shows the ingredient list as printed and flags added sugar, salt and allergens.
| Product | Pack size (as printed) | Country of manufacture (as printed) | First ingredient | Sweetener | Sugars per 100g | Colour |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lee Kum Kee Hoisin (US 8.5oz) | 8.5oz | not stated | Sugar | Sugar | 46 g | Caramel + Red 40 |
| Lee Kum Kee Hoisin (397g international) | 397g | China (origin of ingredients, OFF) | Sugar | Sugar | Not stated | Colours (150a, 129) |
| Amoy Hoisin | not stated | Hong Kong (OFF entry) | Sugar | Sugar | Not stated | Caramel (E150a) |
| Lee Kum Kee Black Bean Sauce | not stated | not stated | Soy sauce | Sugar | Not stated | Not stated |
| Lee Kum Kee Spicy Black Bean Sauce (FairPrice) | 226g | Hong Kong (FairPrice SG listing) | Salted chilli pepper | White sugar | Not stated | Not stated |
| Singlong Black Bean Sauce | — | — | Not verified | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
Panelled with verbatim lists: 5 products. Seen but not verified: 8 products. Checked 12 November 2026. No prices are shown here: they change weekly and would go stale.
Pack size: 8.5oz · Made in: not stated (as printed)
Ingredients (Open Food Facts (US listing — secondary) + EWG (same list)): Sugar, water, fermented soybean paste (water, salt, soybeans, wheat flour), salt, sweet potato powder, caramel color, modified corn starch, sesame paste, dehydrated garlic, spices, salted chili peppers (chili peppers, salt), acetic acid, red 40
Allergens: gluten, sesame, soybeans. Per-100g nutrition from OFF: 225 kcal, fat 2.3g, saturated fat not stated, carbs 51.2g, sugars 46g (added sugars 45g), protein 1.9g, sodium 2560mg (salt 6.4g). Flag: US-market recipe with Red 40 (E129) and no potassium sorbate in this listing; the international 397g recipe differs — see below. SG pack not verified. Allergen: gluten, sesame, soy Via: OFF US SG pack unverified
Pack size: 397g · Made in: China (origin of ingredients, OFF) (as printed)
Ingredients (Open Food Facts (international listing — secondary)): Sugar, Water, Fermented Soybean Paste (Water, Salt, Soybeans, Corn Starch), Salt, Colours (150a, 129), Modified Corn Starch (1422), Rice Vinegar, Sweet Potato Powder, Sesame Paste, Dehydrated Garlic, Spices, Salted Chili Peppers (Chili Peppers, Salt)
Origin of ingredients: China (OFF). Labels: vegetarian, vegan, no flavour enhancer. Differences from the US recipe: corn starch instead of wheat flour in the soybean paste, rice vinegar added, colours given as (150a, 129) instead of 'caramel color' plus 'red 40', and no potassium sorbate. Panelled separately; the two lists must not be merged. No per-100g nutrition verified for this variant. Origin: China (ingredients) Allergen: gluten, sesame, soy Via: OFF SG pack unverified
Pack size: not stated · Made in: Hong Kong (OFF entry) (as printed)
Ingredients (Open Food Facts (OCR transcription — secondary; read with caution)): Sugar, soya bean salty fermented (36.5%) (soya bean, wheat flour, salt, water), rice vinegar, water, colour: caramel (E150a), salt, sesame oil, chili pepper
Flag: the OFF entry for this product is OCR-damaged — the raw text contains garbled fragments ('refliì fraines', 'door/lmpofté foods') and the fermented soybean share is given as 36.5%. The list above is the best readable reconstruction and is panelled with this warning; the SG pack must be checked before this list is treated as settled. Amoy is owned by Ajinomoto and manufactured in Hong Kong per the same entry. Allergens: gluten, sesame, soybeans. Allergen: gluten, sesame, soy OCR garbled Via: OFF SG pack unverified
Pack size: not stated · Made in: not stated (as printed)
Ingredients (Thompsons Food Service (UK foodservice, manufacturer data — secondary)): Soy Sauce (water, salt, SOYBEANS, WHEAT flour), Fermented Black Beans 18% (black SOYBEANS 83%, salt, water), Sugar, Water, Salt, Dehydrated Garlic, Salted Chilli Peppers (Chilli Peppers, Salt), Ginger, SOYBEAN Oil, Fish Extract (ANCHOVY (FISH), Salt), Rice Wine (water, rice, WHEAT), Modified Corn Starch
Fermented black beans at 18% (themselves 83% black soybeans). Contains fish extract (anchovy) — so this black bean sauce is not vegetarian, unlike the hoisin. Also contains rice wine. Flag: UK foodservice source; SG pack not verified. Allergen: soy, wheat, fish Via: UK foodservice SG pack unverified
Pack size: 226g · Made in: Hong Kong (FairPrice SG listing) (as printed)
Ingredients (FairPrice ingredient section (SG listing)): Salted Chilli Pepper, Soya Bean Oil, Fermented Black Beans (Black Beans, Salt, Water), Water, White Sugar, Sesame Oil, Fermented Soya Bean Paste (Water, Salt, Soya Bean, Wheat), Ginger, Garlic, Shallot, Salt, Chili Pepper Powder, Flavour Enhancers (Monosodium Glutamate, Disodium 5-Inosinate, Disodium 5-Guanylate)
The only panelled product on this page with a FairPrice SG ingredient section — the strongest source on the page. Salted chilli pepper first, then oil, then fermented black beans; flavour enhancers MSG, E631 and E627 all present. Contains soya bean and wheat. No per-100g nutrition verified for this product. Allergen: soy, wheat Via: FairPrice SG list
All figures in the first table are as sold, per 100 g / 100 ml. Salt and sodium: salt = sodium × 2.5. The table shows sodium as printed (in mg) with the salt equivalent in brackets. Sodium is not presented as salt, and salt is not presented as sodium.
Total vs added sugars: most Singapore packs list total sugars, not added sugars. A total-sugars figure is never labelled here as “added sugar”. Where a source states an added-sugars figure separately, it is noted. The ingredient list remains the evidence for added sugar (sugar, glucose-fructose syrup, molasses, honey) versus naturally occurring sugars (fructose in fruit, lactose in milk).
Open Food Facts is a community database and is flagged as secondary where used: the pack and the retailer nutrition section take precedence if they disagree. Figures marked “not stated” were not in the source retrieved; they are not estimated, borrowed from another variant, or copied across flavours. No Nutri-Grade is quoted or assigned on this page: Nutri-Grade applies to drinks, and none of these products carries a printed Nutri-Grade on its Singapore pack as verified in this pass.
| Product ↕ | Energy ↕ | Protein ↕ | Total fat ↕ | Saturated fat ↕ | Carbohydrate ↕ | Sugars ↕ | Sodium (salt equiv.) ↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lee Kum Kee Hoisin (US 8.5oz) | 225 kcal | 1.9 g | 2.3 g | not stated | 51.2 g | 46 g | 2560 mg (salt 6.4 g) |
Click a column header to sort low to high; click again for high to low. “not stated” always sorts last — it is missing data, not zero.
Conflicts flagged, not silently resolved: Lee Kum Kee Hoisin — the US 8.5oz list (wheat flour in the soybean paste, 'red 40', no rice vinegar, no potassium sorbate) conflicts with the international 397g list (corn starch in the soybean paste, colours (150a, 129), rice vinegar added). Both are panelled separately. The S&B/Weee Japanese-market LKK hoisin list differs again (soy sauce instead of fermented soybean paste, salt equivalent 6.6g per 100g) and is recorded in the research notes, not panelled. Amoy — the OFF entry is OCR-garbled; the panelled list is a reconstruction, flagged as such.
Seen but not verified (nutrition):
Checked 12 November 2026 from: FairPrice ingredient section (Lee Kum Kee Spicy Black Bean Sauce 226g, SG listing); Open Food Facts (Lee Kum Kee Hoisin 8.5oz US — ingredients and per-100g nutrition; Lee Kum Kee Hoisin 397g international; Amoy Hoisin — OCR-garbled entry; Lee Kum Kee Sweet Hoisin 567g); EWG (LKK Hoisin US list corroboration); Thompsons Food Service UK (Lee Kum Kee Black Bean Sauce — ingredients); S&B/Weee (Japanese-market LKK Hoisin list and per-100g salt equivalent, recorded in notes only). No SG pack was available for any panelled product except via the FairPrice ingredient section. Cold Storage publishes no ingredient list on any product page.